Blog Hero Image

Posted by Craig Basinger on Feb 6th, 2023

Rent This Rally, Don't Buy It

2023 has started off with a bang – a good bang, that is. After a tough 2022, which saw most asset classes, including stocks and bonds, moving lower, 2023 has started off on the right foot, with stocks jumping higher and bonds moving up too. This is the sweet spot. Inflation has started to cool, emboldening some central banks to arrest their interest rate hiking ways that dominated 2022. The Bank of Canada hiked in January and announced a pause. The omni-important Fed may be nearing this point as well. Currently, the market is pricing in one or two more 25bps hikes for the Fed.

Meanwhile, Q4 earnings are coming in reasonably well despite cooling predictions. The widely forecast deceleration of earnings growth remains elusive, but it is coming. Inflation is positive for corporate sales, which is starting to slow but remains positive. And while the economy is beginning to slow, it remains decent with lingering tailwinds. China reopening is helping, as is Europe's management of their tight energy situation during the winter months. Put it together, the narrative around a soft landing has gained some traction.

From our 2023 Outlook – so far, this year is going according to expectations:

2023 should start off decently as inflation comes down a bit more, partially alleviating the market's biggest fear. Plus, a little January effect could certainly help. However, less inflation will start to accelerate slowing corporate earnings. And the wealth effect of falling equity/bond markets over the past year plus delayed economic impact of rate hikes and higher yields will cause economic growth to fall significantly. This could trigger the final leg down of the bear and create the better buying opportunity, hopefully sometime in the first half of 2023, as the market begins to look through the trough and rally back to be positive on the year.

Stocks and bonds to start 2023

Enjoy this sweet spot, as it is unlikely to last. Take a step back from the month-to-month gyrations; inflation got out of control in 2022, which elicited a very aggressive response from central banks. The speed of rate hikes and the magnitude were breathtaking. This solution to inflation, hiking rates, works because it slows economic activity with a delayed impact. We are now seeing inflation begin to soften, and the slowing economic growth should become increasingly evident next. While a soft landing is not impossible, given global economic growth is coming down from a 5.8% pace in 2021 to 3% in 2022 to ?% in 2023 combined with this magnitude of rate hikes, it may be a long shot. This may harken to bullseyeing womp rats in a T-16.

But don't mistake our tone for bearishness. We remain constructive for 2023, as it should be a better year than 2022. But don't get too excited about the markets' strong upward move out of the gates, either. This 'inflation relief rally' may have more to go, but January is often an odd month due to tax losses, rebalancing, and the often renewed optimism a new year brings for investors. The road ahead still has many challenging twists and turns likely in store. And given the size of the bounce, a twist to the downside keeps becoming more likely. Rent this rally, don't buy it.

Market Cycle

Over the past few months, we have commented that our Market Cycle indicators were hovering just above the danger zone and fully expected this metric to drop as fundamentals such as earnings and valuations weaken. That has started to come to fruition. Compared with last month, one signal from both the U.S. economy and the global economy turned bearish. But the drop really came from 'Fundamentals,' which dropped from 8 bullish of a possible 12 to only 4 bullish. A rise in equity prices pushed some valuations from bullish to bearish. Meanwhile, earnings growth is slowing quickly in both Canada and the U.S.  International fundamentals are still looking decent thanks to Europe managing the winter and China reopening.

Market cycle indicators are not encouraging
Market cycle indicators
Portfolio tilts

Earnings – Unfounded Worries

So far, the fear of this earnings season has been misguided, and the current earnings season has not been as bad as feared. Markets have rallied in part because of this. We're still seeing a solid number of companies reporting positive earnings surprises, yet we'd point out the decreasing magnitude compared with the past couple of years. To date, 251 S&P 500 companies have reported 4Q results. Reported sales growth has been 5.1%, and earnings are down by -3.6% -- surprising consensus estimates by +1.0% and +1.3%, respectively. The average stock price rose +0.78% post-results.

Inflation helps with the top line, and companies have thus far managed to control expenses. Consumer Discretionary has been a recent outperformer with an average 12.2% earnings beat and an impressive average 2.2% move in the average stock price. Utilities have lagged on averaging missing expectations and dropping over -2% post-results.

Nearly 30% of reported companies are reporting revenue declines, and 35% have a decline in earnings. Those looking for a broad fundamental confirmation to drive the next leg higher for markets might have to look elsewhere. We continue to have concerns over the coming quarters for a continued deterioration in company fundaments. On the plus side, this earnings season has failed to give markets an excuse to resume their sell-off, with companies, on average, managing to beat already lowered expectations moderately. The chart below shows that the current expected earnings drawdown from the recent peak is around 6%. Not even remotely consistent with a recession scenario.

Global earnings have not adjusted enough

Looking ahead, analysts expect earnings declines for the first half of 2023 but earnings growth for the second half of 2023. For Q1 2023 and Q2 2023, analysts are projecting earnings declines of -5% and -4 %, respectively. In the back half of the year, projections are far more optimistic, with Q3 and Q4 projected earnings growth of 3.93% and 8.2%, respectively.

Recessions Are Rarely Reflected in Forward Estimates

The forward price-to-earnings ratio for the S&P 500 stands at 18.6. It's one of the most common valuation metrics to gauge how cheap or expensive the stock market is. It's based on a consensus of forecasts from sell-side analysts for the coming 12 months. One of the big issues anytime you use consensus earnings forecasts is that they usually overstate expected earnings heading into a recession. Forward earnings estimates do decline (-5% from peak currently) but underestimate the inevitable surprises that overwhelmingly tend to be negative. If as reported earnings for this year decline just 20% from 2022 levels (an average recession), then the PE ratio would be 22, and hardly a bargain.

The chart below plots actual earnings per share (EPS) compared with the EPS estimates from 12 months prior. During recessions, reported earnings come in around 20%-30% below the estimates from 12 months prior. Presently, current earnings are still 10% above what was expected at the beginning of 2022, but the trend is falling. Keep in mind a year ago, nobody was expecting a Fed Funds Rate of 4.75% either, and those increased borrowing costs will continue to crimp demand when the full effect of the hikes fully reveal themselves in the economy and consumer spending patterns.

Consensus forecasts earnings rarely pan out as expected

While it's our base case that there will be an economic slowdown and possibly even a recession later this year, the consensus has yet to fully price this change in the macro environment into their forecasts. As noted earlier, estimates have fallen just 6% from their peak.

Where to From Here?

Below is a matrix showing projected S&P 500 levels given a number of economic scenarios for earnings growth and what the market will pay for a $1 of earnings. From a very shallow recession with a 5% drop from current trailing earnings to an average recession with a decline of -20%. We've also included a 'goldilocks scenario' with earnings growing 5% from here. On the left-hand side are various PE multiples and, within the matrix, the corresponding S&P levels with the resulting percentage change from where we are now. It is a sobering exercise to go through it and realize that a mild recession and multiples dropping down a few points to 16x earnings would bring the S&P 500 down to the 3,200 level. A sizeable drop, given the rally up to recent levels.

S&P 500 Projections

Overall, the current and expected earnings drawdown for the S&P 500 is not consistent with any type of real recession scenario. Should a recession come, we would expect earnings to decline far more than the current estimates as they seem too optimistic in the 2H and underestimate two large negative forces facing corporate America. Continued rising costs (albeit at a slower rate) and deteriorating demand as higher borrowing costs crimp consumer spending.

An expected after-effect of bear markets is a serious shift in investor psychology. Given the rampant low-quality rebound year to date, it would appear that the psychology of markets has NOT changed. The beginning of 2023 has so far felt very similar to 2021, just without the GameStop mania. Investors are still in that permanent QE mindset, despite a completely different state of affairs. There is and always will be a consequence to valuations; they currently appear overly confident. Central banks will not likely be able to flip a switch and stimulate the economy with reckless abandon as they did in 2020. Our base case is that a recession remains on the horizon, and current market conditions are not reflective of the 'old normal.' Instead, the 'new normal' mentality from the preceding decade has taken hold once again.

Japan Trip #2

After becoming positive on Japan last summer, it's time for another visit as much has changed. Japanese Yield Curve Control continues to be a hot topic throughout the global markets. A few weeks ago, another opportunity arose for the BOJ to abandon yield curve control and attempt to reign in their 40+ year high inflation. However, the final decision was made to remain steadfast with the program. We also hold strong in our beliefs that this decision was made from a short-term viewpoint and the economic situation will encourage their hand into repairing the currency and reigning in their multi-decade high inflation.

There is good and bad news if the BOJ does decide to abandon yield curve control. The good news is that our unhedged exposure to the yen should spike much higher, posting much stronger returns for us Canadians. The bad news is, abandoning their loose monetary policy could prove challenging for the Japanese stock market in what would be seen as a significant move towards fiscal tightening.

We saw the first sign of it back in December when the BOJ adjusted the policy slightly, allowing their 10-year bond yields to have a wider band of +/- 50 bps instead of 25. We watched the Japanese market fall while the yen showed some strength. We expect a similar event if the BOJ decides to abandon the policy altogether; however, it will likely be more impactful. In our view, the positive move in the yen for us as Canadians will outweigh the drop in the Japanese market resulting in a net positive return for multi-asset portfolios.

Over the last several months, the recovery of the Japanese yen has started to form. Back in July, when we initiated a position in Japan, you could get 35% more yen per loonie compared with a couple of years prior to that. With the strength in the yen over the last few months you can get about 21% more yen per loonie. That move came from the expectation that the BOJ would have to step in an attempt to reverse the weakness. As we saw the first sign of this in December, one has to believe they cannot continue to buy bonds at this pace, inflating their balance sheet and crushing their currency.

As Japan holds loose and the rest of the world holds tight, global spreads against Japan have remained elevated. In our eyes, it does not matter who blinks first. Whether the world becomes a little more dovish due to a recession or Japan is more hawkish to catch up to the globe, the unhedged currency exposure to Japan will continue to prove rewarding.

Who will blink first?

The easing of lockdowns in Asian economies is another reason to be bullish in Japan. Emerging markets remain expensive and historically have underperformed during a recession. That brings cause for concern for portfolios that are perhaps loading up in China or other emerging economies. That leaves investors with a decision to replicate a "U.S. pandemic recovery" type of event in Asia. How does one do so without too much exposure to those underdeveloped economies? Our answer remains to be overweight Japan, the second largest developed economy in the world. A line from our past market ethos sums up the situation perfectly:

As a developed economy, Japan would benefit from the reopening economic boost of the region while being less at risk from the emerging market headwinds.

Awash with earnings

The makeup of their current corporate landscape is another reason to feel comfortable with Japan. Earnings remain strong, which has valuations well below the average of the last ten years. The lower currency has proved well for Japanese exports as their goods have been less expensive compared with goods priced in stronger currencies. Yields remain strong as companies in Japan continue to increase cash flow back to investors through dividends and share buybacks. From a market perspective, Japan is poised for strong growth barring any additional major economic setbacks.

Reaping the benefits

The simple thesis moving forward comes down to inflation being elevated (from their standards), and the BOJ will likely have to step in and be more aggressive than they have been. When that happens remains the question. The current term for Haruhiko Kuroda, the governor of the BOJ, will be up at the beginning of April. Perhaps the new governor will bring in a shift in policy that will prove to be more hawkish, resulting in a reduction in inflation and strength to the yen.

Over the last couple of months, we have really started to see some of the benefits that bring our thesis to life. As the yen strengthened, the local currency index is up +5.0% while the Nikkei in Canadian dollars is up approximately +15.0%. The story has been playing out well to start, but there are always risks to any investment decision in a portfolio. A prolonged recession, a mistake by the BOJ, or another spike in lockdowns are a few that could impact Japan. However, we continue to believe that the rewards outweigh the risks in this investment decision. Being international investors purchasing a currency at levels not seen since the early 2000s provides a substantial buffer against the risk.

Getting Real With Inflation

For years in almost every investor's financial plan, inflation wasn't given much thought and had been assumed to be around 2% – just a simple input into the plan for the journey ahead. Well, the past couple of years may challenge that benign assumption of 2%. We are in the camp that inflation will trend lower this year as changed pandemic behaviours normalize, supply issues resolve, and maybe even peace. But looking further downfield, we believe inflation will be more volatile and the average likely higher than in decades past.

Inflation had remained low for decades thanks to a number of long-term trends – demographic, technological advancements, globalization of trade, peace and, in the most recent decade, a degree of deleveraging. Some of these trends appear to have either changed or softened. The demographic transition to more savers is starting to give way to more decummulators. Globalization is now facing onshoring. The world is less peaceful. Energy transition is also inflationary. And the disinflationary blanket that sat atop the global economy in the 2010s is clearly gone. Maybe a 2% inflation assumption is a tad optimistic.

If inflation is going to be higher in the years ahead, this has portfolio construction implications [see 'Thoughts on the next cycle' in our recent report, Preparing for the next bull]. A higher allocation to investments that can keep up with inflation would help alleviate this new planning risk. Equities do well in keeping up with inflation, primarily because earnings are nominal and enjoy a lift from inflation. Some markets more than others. Even better, real assets.

The term real assets has a rather wide interpretation in the investment world. Commodities, real estate, real return bonds, infrastructure, and the list goes on. Among the many sub-categories of real assets, commodities and, to a lesser degree, real estate, have very strong long-term historical relationships with inflation. Thus, allocations that include real assets, potentially with a commodity/real estate tilt, can help protect a portfolio and financial plan against inflation.

Commodity prices and inflation - a long-term relationship

As recent evidence, global markets declined in 2022 largely due to high inflation, while real assets held up very well, somewhat offsetting the higher inflation period.

Commodity Supply and Demand – One could argue there has been an underinvestment in supply capacity for many commodities that have been exacerbated by the conflict in Ukraine. This has also encouraged greater diversity in supply sources. Meanwhile, on the demand side, energy transition is changing which commodities are seeing greater changes in consumption, creating a healthy supply-demand situation.

However, with the FOMC raising the cost of capital over the past year from 0.25% - 4.75%, there is a rising risk of recession and/or slowing economic growth. This is a headwind for commodity prices on the demand side but worth noting that some economies around the world have already slowed and are now improving. China, for instance, which has suffered a multi-year contraction in housing and a zero covid policy, is now seeing growth rebound as both these headwinds dissipate. And when it comes to commodities, China and other emerging economies matter much more than whether or not the U.S. economy contracts.

Agricultural commodities have seen significant strength this year, particularly grains, due to the high demand and supply shortage due to the disruption in Ukrainian exports. Russia's invasion of Ukraine has been a key driver for commodity prices this year. Prices for many major crops are projected to decline in the near term as global production responds to the high prices of recent years.  Nonetheless, after these initial price declines, long-term growth in global demand for agricultural products and continued biofuel demand hold prices for many crops above pre-2007 levels.

Infrastructure/Real Estate Real estate valuations and cash flows held steady last year despite the market turmoil. The infrastructure market is expected to slow down with the higher interest rate environment pushing the forecast towards the downside in the short run. However, the consensus of consumer sentiment, in the long run, shows that people are majorly optimistic in the long run and, in turn, reflects the ongoing attractiveness of global real assets as a theme. Inflation is at its peak, and central banks are still hiking rates, but at a slower pace – the largest headwind for those affected is now subsiding.

Real estate market sentiment

Precious Metals –Gold prices were hindered in 2022 by aggressive central banks hiking interest rates to combat the elevated levels of inflation and also dominated by the strong dollar. As we adventure further into the year, expectations for inflation may have peaked; however, we must keep in mind that the only projection is modestly higher equilibrium inflation rates over the next decade. With this supporting the theme of underinvestment in real assets and higher strength in the asset class moving forward, there are clear signs that the strength of gold is not its price rising in the short term but the long-term stability of the asset that provides great value when added into a portfolio.

Investment Implications

Adding real assets into an investment portfolio can help protect the portfolio and a financial plan from inflation risk, helping retain its value over time. Based on our current portfolio construction tilts, real assets have been an overweight for some time and will likely remain so. And while there are many strategies within the real asset spectrum, we believe those that focus on commodity and real estate exposure provide the biggest bang for the buck in terms of portfolio inflation protection.

— Craig Basinger is the Chief Market Strategist at Purpose Investments
— Derek Benedet is a Portfolio Manager at Purpose Investments
— Brett Gustafson is an Analyst at Purpose Investments
— Gloria Huynh is an Investment Analyst at Purpose Investments

Get the latest market insights to your inbox each week.

Sources: Charts are sourced to Bloomberg L. P.

The content of this document is for informational purposes only and is not being provided in the context of an offering of any securities described herein, nor is it a recommendation or solicitation to buy, hold or sell any security. The information is not investment advice, nor is it tailored to the needs or circumstances of any investor. Information contained in this document is not, and under no circumstances is it to be construed as, an offering memorandum, prospectus, advertisement or public offering of securities. No securities commission or similar regulatory authority has reviewed this document, and any representation to the contrary is an offence. Information contained in this document is believed to be accurate and reliable, however, we cannot guarantee that it is complete or current at all times. The information provided is subject to change without notice.

Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees and expenses all may be associated with investment funds. Please read the prospectus before investing. If the securities are purchased or sold on a stock exchange, you may pay more or receive less than the current net asset value. Investment funds are not guaranteed, their values change frequently and past performance may not be repeated. Certain statements in this document are forward-looking. Forward-looking statements ("FLS") are statements that are predictive in nature, depend on or refer to future events or conditions, or that include words such as "may," "will," "should," "could," "expect," "anticipate," intend," "plan," "believe," "estimate" or other similar expressions. Statements that look forward in time or include anything other than historical information are subject to risks and uncertainties, and actual results, actions or events could differ materially from those set forth in the FLS. FLS are not guarantees of future performance and are by their nature based on numerous assumptions. Although the FLS contained in this document are based upon what Purpose Investments and the portfolio manager believe to be reasonable assumptions, Purpose Investments and the portfolio manager cannot assure that actual results will be consistent with these FLS. The reader is cautioned to consider the FLS carefully and not to place undue reliance on the FLS. Unless required by applicable law, it is not undertaken, and specifically disclaimed, that there is any intention or obligation to update or revise FLS, whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise.

Craig Basinger, CFA

Craig Basinger is the Chief Market Strategist at Purpose Investments. With over 25 years of investment experience, Craig combines an educational foundation in economics & psychology with years of experience in both fundamental and quantitative research. A long-term student of the markets, Craig’s thoughts and insights can be seen in his Market Ethos publications and through his regular contributions on BNN.

Craig and his team bring a transparent and cost-efficient approach to investment management. The team provides asset allocation OCIO services and directly manages over $1 billion in assets. The team manages dividend mandates, quantitative risk reduction strategies and asset allocation services.

Derek Benedet

Derek is a Portfolio Manager at Purpose Investments. He has worked for the past sixteen years in the investment industry with experience at CIBC Wood Gundy, GMP Securities as well as Richardson Wealth. He is a Chartered Market Technician (CMT), a designation obtained through expertise in technical analyses and is granted by the Market Technicians Association. His unique investment approach combines technical analysis, quantitative finance and fundamental analysis.

Brett Gustafson

Brett is a Portfolio Analyst at Purpose. He is responsible for relationship management and advisor support and focuses heavily on portfolio analytics for advisors, our own proprietary models, as well as equity research. With over nine years of experience in the investment industry, Brett started his career out as an Investment Advisor at a Canadian independent asset management firm where he cared for several high-net-worth families. Brett graduated from the University of Calgary with a Bachelor of Commerce degree. He is currently pursuing his CFA designation with the goal of becoming a Portfolio Manager.